Top 10 White Nose Tackles of All Time Who Dominated the Trenches
White nose tackles have carved out a unique niche in NFL history, blending unmatched strength with astute football intelligence. This group of formidable athletes includes legends like Fred Smerlas, whose dominance at the line of scrimmage forced offenses to adapt.
Tim Krumrie’s ferocity on the field paced countless games, and Bob Baumhower’s steadfast presence bolstered agile defenses. The role these players fulfilled goes beyond ordinary recognition, solidifying their legacies as some of the most impactful forces in the trenches.
The Top 10 White Nose Tackles of All Time represent the pinnacle of skill and tenacity at the position, defining what it means to control the line and disrupt offensive schemes. This list highlights the exceptional contributions of players who redefined defensive play and left a lasting imprint on the game.
This site uses affiliate links. We may earn a commission when you click at no cost to you.
Table of Contents
#10. Tony Casillas
Position: Nose Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’3″, 291 lbs
Teams: Atlanta Falcons (1986–1990), Dallas Cowboys (1991–1993, 1996–1997), New York Jets (1994–1995), Kansas City Chiefs (1998)
Tony Casillas was a key anchor in the trenches, known for his relentless drive and exceptional ability to clog running lanes. A standout at the University of Oklahoma, Casillas transitioned smoothly into the NFL, quickly becoming a force on the defensive line.
His time with the Dallas Cowboys solidified his legacy, as he played an essential role in their back-to-back Super Bowl victories in the early ’90s. Casillas’ strength at the point of attack and his knack for disrupting plays made him a valuable asset to every team he played for.
His durability and leadership were just as impactful off the field, helping establish him as one of the Top 10 White Nose Tackles of All Time. Casillas’ consistent performance across multiple teams demonstrated his adaptability and unwavering effectiveness in the middle of the defense.
This site uses affiliate links. We may earn a commission when you click at no cost to you.
Accolades:
- 2× Super Bowl Champion (XXVII, XXVIII)
- First-team All-American (1985)
- College Football Hall of Fame inductee (2004)
#9. Bill Pickel
Position: Nose Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’5″, 270 lbs
Teams: Los Angeles Raiders (1983–1990), New York Jets (1991–1993)
Bill Pickel was a disruptive force on the defensive line, using his size and quick first step to wreak havoc in the backfield. Known for his ability to shed blockers and collapse pockets, Pickel played a critical role for the Raiders during the mid-to-late ’80s.
His consistency and knack for getting to the quarterback made him a versatile lineman who excelled both as a run-stopper and a pass-rusher.
Pickel’s intense style of play fit perfectly with the rough, hard-nosed identity of the Raiders, and he earned respect across the league for his tenacity and durability. Pickel’s impact on the Raiders’ defensive front remains memorable.
Accolades:
- Super Bowl Champion (XVIII)
- 2× All-Pro Second Team (1984, 1985)
#8. Jeff Wright
Position: Nose Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’2″, 270 lbs
Teams: Buffalo Bills (1988–1994)
Jeff Wright played a crucial role in the Buffalo Bills’ dominant defenses during their unprecedented run of four consecutive Super Bowl appearances in the early ’90s. Known for his quickness off the snap and relentless pursuit, Wright consistently disrupted offensive lines and clogged running lanes, making life easier for the Bills’ linebackers.
His ability to slip past blockers and collapse the pocket often forced quarterbacks into hurried decisions.
Though he may not have received the same accolades as some of his contemporaries, Wright’s contributions were pivotal to the Bills’ defensive success. Wright’s presence in the middle of the defense remains a key part of Buffalo’s storied history.
Accolades:
- 4× AFC Champion (1990–1993)
- Key contributor to four consecutive Super Bowl appearances
- Buffalo Bills Wall of Fame Nominee
#7. Greg Kragen
Position: Nose Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’3″, 263 lbs
Teams: Denver Broncos (1985–1993), Kansas City Chiefs (1994), Carolina Panthers (1995–1997)
Greg Kragen was a key defensive cog for the Denver Broncos during their three Super Bowl runs in the late ’80s. Renowned for his tenacity and motor, Kragen was a classic example of an underdog who outworked the competition, consistently holding his ground against larger offensive linemen.
His ability to disrupt the interior run game and provide interior pass rush made him indispensable to the Broncos’ defensive schemes.
Kragen’s contributions extended beyond Denver, playing a pivotal leadership role with the expansion Carolina Panthers, helping guide their defense to an NFC Championship appearance in just their second season. His consistency and toughness place him firmly among the best white NFL defensive players of all time.
Accolades:
- Pro Bowl Selection (1989)
- 3× Super Bowl Appearances with the Broncos
- Key leader in the Panthers’ 1996 NFC Championship run
#6. Jim Burt
- Position: Nose Tackle
- Height/Weight: 6’1″, 260 lbs
- Teams: New York Giants (1981-1988), San Francisco 49ers (1989-1991)
Jim Burt was an integral part of the New York Giants‘ formidable defense in the 1980s. Known for his grit and tenacity, Burt played as a nose tackle, anchoring the defensive line with his robust, unwavering presence.
He was a key contributor to the Giants’ success, culminating in their victory in Super Bowl XXI.
Burt’s famous hit on 49ers quarterback Joe Montana during the 1986 playoffs is often cited as a turning point in the Giants’ championship run. His physical style of play and ability to disrupt opposing offenses solidified his legacy as a defensive stalwart.
- Accolades:
- 1× Super Bowl Champion (XXI)
- Pro Bowl Selection (1986)
- Recorded 591 tackles, 20.5 sacks, and 10 fumble recoveries during his career.
#5. Bob Baumhower
Position: Nose Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’5″, 261 lbs
Teams: Miami Dolphins (1977–1986)
Bob Baumhower anchored the Dolphins‘ defensive line during their dominant years under Don Shula, becoming a pivotal part of Miami’s renowned “Killer B’s” defense. His combination of size, strength, and football IQ allowed him to dominate opponents and consistently disrupt offensive game plans.
This site uses affiliate links. We may earn a commission when you click at no cost to you.
Baumhower was a master at reading plays and clogging rushing lanes, often forcing teams to adjust their schemes.
His role in leading the Dolphins to multiple playoff appearances highlights his value as a defensive stalwart. Baumhower’s impact resonates throughout Dolphins history.
Accolades:
- 5× Pro Bowl Selection (1979–1983)
- 2× First-team All-Pro (1981, 1983)
- Miami Dolphins Honor Roll
#4. Louie Kelcher
Position: Nose Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’5″, 280 lbs
Teams: San Diego Chargers (1975–1983), San Francisco 49ers (1984)
Louie Kelcher was the heart and soul of the San Diego Chargers’ defensive line throughout the late 1970s and early ’80s. Known for his massive frame and quick burst, Kelcher overwhelmed offensive linemen with his blend of size and athleticism.
His ability to dominate the trenches made him a nightmare for opposing quarterbacks and running backs alike. Kelcher’s relentless pursuit of the ball, combined with his leadership qualities, helped anchor the Chargers’ defense during a competitive era in the AFC.
In the twilight of his career, Kelcher earned a Super Bowl ring with the 49ers, adding a crowning achievement to an already illustrious career. His inclusion as one of the best white NFL players is a testament to his versatility and enduring excellence on the defensive front.
Accolades:
- 3× Pro Bowl Selection (1977, 1978, 1980)
- First-team All-Pro (1978)
- San Diego Chargers Hall of Fame
- Super Bowl Champion (XIX)
#3. Tim Krumrie
- Position: Nose Tackle
- Height/Weight: 6’3″, 274 lbs
- Teams: Cincinnati Bengals (1983-1994)
Tim Krumrie was a formidable force on the defensive line for the Cincinnati Bengals. Known for his gritty playing style and relentless work ethic, Krumrie became a cornerstone of the Bengals’ defense during his 12-year career.
His resilience was exemplified during Super Bowl XXIII, where his courageous but ill-fated participation resulted in a broken leg—yet he returned to play two more seasons at a high level. Krumrie’s legacy is defined by his ability to inspire both teammates and fans with his sheer determination and dedication to the game.
- Accolades:
- 2× Pro Bowl selection (1987, 1988)
- 1× All-Pro selection (1988)
- Cincinnati Bengals Ring of Honor
- Played in Super Bowl XXIII
#2. Joe Klecko
Position: Nose Tackle / Defensive Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’3″, 263 lbs
Teams: New York Jets (1977–1987), Indianapolis Colts (1988)
Joe Klecko was the heart of the New York Jets’ famed “New York Sack Exchange” and one of the most versatile and dominant defensive linemen of his era. Known for his relentless work ethic and incredible strength, Klecko could line up at multiple positions but made his most significant impact at nose tackle.
His ability to disrupt offenses and control the line of scrimmage earned him widespread respect from both teammates and opponents.
Klecko’s tenacity and football IQ were pivotal in leading the Jets to playoff appearances in the early ’80s. Despite battling injuries, Klecko’s consistency and leadership never wavered, securing his legacy as one of the top 10 New York Jets of all time.
Accolades:
- 4× Pro Bowl Selection (1981, 1983–1985)
- 2× First-team All-Pro (1981, 1985)
- NFL Defensive Player of the Year Runner-Up (1981)
- New York Jets Ring of Honor
- Pro Football Hall of Fame (2023)
#1. Fred Smerlas
Position: Nose Tackle
Height/Weight: 6’3″, 270 lbs
Teams: Buffalo Bills (1979–1989), San Francisco 49ers (1990), New England Patriots (1991)
Fred Smerlas stands at the top of the list as the most dominant white nose tackle in NFL history. A cornerstone of the Buffalo Bills’ defense for over a decade, Smerlas was known for his power, durability, and unrelenting aggression in the trenches.
His ability to shed blockers and stuff the run made him a nightmare for opposing offenses. Smerlas’ leadership and intensity helped shape the identity of the Bills’ defense during the ’80s, and his contributions laid the foundation for the team’s success in the early ’90s.
His five Pro Bowl selections highlight his consistent excellence at one of the most physically demanding positions in football. As the undisputed leader of the Top 10 White Nose Tackles of All Time, Smerlas’ legacy continues to inspire defensive linemen today.
Accolades:
- 5× Pro Bowl Selection (1980–1984)
- First-team All-Pro (1982)
- Buffalo Bills Wall of Fame
- Boston College Hall of Fame
